National Indian Country Clearinghouse on Sexual Assault

Tribal Court Prosecution

 

flagA sexual assault committed in Indian Country by an Indian perpetrator may be prosecuted in both tribal and federal courts without the threat of double jeopardy.  It is possible to prosecute and convict a perpetrator of sexual assault in two, separate jurisdictions and to impose two, separate criminal penalties for the crime. Coordination of tribal sexual assault investigations and prosecutions with federal authorities is important to ensure successful dual prosecution of a perpetrator in both tribal and federal courts. 

 

Communication, collaboration, cooperation, and mutual respect are the hallmarks of a productive, successful working relationship between tribal and federal criminal justice professionals. There is a greater likelihood of securing sexual assault convictions when tribal and federal agencies have established solid, collaborative working relationships.

 

 

Tribal criminal justice professionals should meet regularly with their federal counterparts to clarify each jurisdiction’s roles and responsibilities in the investigation and prosecution of sexual assault crimes. Formal protocols or clearly defined informal agreements can reduce the confusion and overlap that sometimes occur when multiple jurisdictions are investigating and prosecuting the same criminal acts. These protocols or informal agreements can address such important issues as:

 

 

♦  Which jurisdiction will issue a search and/or arrest warrant?

 

♦  Which agency will coordinate victim interviews to reduce the number of times and persons interviewing a victim?

 

♦  Which agency will maintain evidence and the chain of custody over evidence?

 

 

Although the federal definition of sexual assault may differ from the definition of sexual assault contained in a tribal code, federal and tribal prosecutors will often utilize the same evidence, witnesses, and arguments at trial. It is important to coordinate access to evidence and witnesses so that they will be available for trial in each and every jurisdiction where the perpetrator can be prosecuted.

Publications:


Additional Resources - (3)

Protocols - (2)

 

Full Publication List

 

 

Featured Publications

 

A Jurisdictional Quandary: Challenges Facing Tribal Governments in Implementing the Full Faith and Credit Provisions of the Violence Against Women Acts

 

A Jurisdictional Quandary: Challenges Facing Tribal Governments in Implementing the Full Faith and Credit Provisions of the Violence Against Women Acts

 

This research paper written by the Melissa L. Tatum and was published by the University of Tulsa College of Law and the Kentucky Law Journal. The article provides in-depth analysis and exploration of the jurisdictional rules that apply to state and to tribes and examine the impact of those different rules on VAWA's Full Faith and Credit Provisions, as well as a model Tribal code for enforcement of foreign protection orders.

 

 

Enhanced Sentencing in Tribal Courts: Lessons Learned from Tribes

 

Enhanced Sentencing in Tribal Courts:  Lessons Learned from Tribes

 

 

 

Tribal Healing to Wellness Courts

 

Tribal Healing to Wellness Courts

 

This 2015 policies and procedures guide created by the Tribal Law and Policy Institute features excerpts from over fifteen different operational Healing to Wellness Court manuals to provide context and showcase the possible variety in options when pulling together what will become the foundational document for your Wellness Court.

 

 

National Indian Country Clearinghouse on Sexual Assault, a project by the Southwest Center for Law and Policy © 2017

This project was supported by  Grant No. 2011-TA-AX-K045 awarded by the Office on Violence Against Women. Points of view in this document are those of the author and do not necessary represent the official position of the U.S. Department of Justice. All rights reserved. | Privacy policy   Login